"Revolution" is an overused term. Yet we are truly in the midst of the
Telecommunications Revolution, a revolution as profound as the
agricultural revolution, the industrial revolution, and the computer
revolution. The Telecommunications Revolution is changing the way we work,
shop, plan, learn, and relate to each other. Telecommunications services
that were unheard of a decade ago are now commonplace. Cell phones,
pagers, personal communications service devices, wireless internet,
digital cable, high-density television, .com companies, satellite dishes,
websites, and e-mail have quickly become a part of everyday life.
While it often seems that telecommunications occurs like magic, in reality
telecommunications relies on physical infrastructure: wires, antennas,
poles, and equipment. Whether these facilities are located within streets
or on private property, local governments are called upon to both
facilitate deployment and protect against their health, safety, and
aesthetic impacts. And if these tasks were not complicated enough, local
governments are required to regulate these facilities within the context
of complex, often obscure state and federal regulations. This challenge is
magnified by the fact that few local governments have telecommunications
departments, leaving the regulatory tasks in many cases to staff who have
little technical background or familiarity with relevant state and federal
regulations. At the same time, many in the telecommunications industry and
in state and federal government have little understanding of local
government procedures or sensitivity to local concerns.
This book is intended as a resource for local government staff, including
attorneys, planners, engineers, and cable franchise administrators, who
deal with these complex issues. It is also intended for telecommunication
company personnel who work with local governments, and for state and
federal government staff who administer regulations implicating local
governments.
Regulating Cable. A primary focus of this book is cable regulation. Local
government has long played the central role in regulating cable
television, both its physical infrastructure as well as cable services.
Cable operators are required to obtain a franchise from local agencies who
typically regulate the construction of systems, the carriage of community
access programming, rates of basic service, and other customer service
matters. On several occasions over the past two decades, Congress has
enacted new legislation that each time has dramatically changed the scope
of local authority over cable; and the Federal Communications Commission
(FCC) has issued countless rulings to implement these changes.
Typically the FCC issues orders that adopt regulations, but often one must
read both the orders and the regulations to understand the full impact on
local government authority. Yet often these orders are issued without the
knowledge of most local government agencies and are printed, if at all, in
publications that generally are not readily available to local staff.
Making matters worse, the courts have issued numerous decisions
interpreting federal and state law, often in unclear or conflicting ways.
This book explains how cable systems work and how they are regulated at
the federal, state, and local levels. It also explains how a new type of
cable-like service, "open video," is regulated.
Regulating Telephone Companies. On the other hand, local governments have
historically played a much more limited role in regulating telephone
companies. Federal and state governments have had exclusive authority to
regulate telephone services. Under California law, telephone companies
have had a statewide franchise to locate facilities within public streets.
As a result, local governments have traditionally only been able to
regulate the time, place, and manner in which telephone companies used
public streets. This required little effort, since typically only one
telephone company served each community. However, deregulation of the
telephone industry has spawned dozens of new telephone companies trying to
install facilities as quickly as possible. As a result, in many
communities numerous telephone companies are constantly digging in the
streets and installing new above-ground equipment pedestals, raising new
issues about managing construction, mitigating damage to street pavement,
and regulating aesthetic impacts of pedestals. Moreover, since telephone
companies have begun to provide a variety of new services beyond voice
communication (such as Internet access, fiber optic data lines, and data
processing services) communities are struggling to determine which
companies and services are subject to local regulation under federal and
state law and whether they can be required to pay compensation for use of
public property. Resolving these issues involves navigating a morass of
federal and state laws, and this book is intended to provide guidance.
Regulating Wireless. While cable and traditional telephone systems largely
use public streets for their facilities, wireless telecommunications
systems frequently use private property to install antennas for
transmitting and receiving signals. The explosion of cellular telephones
has led to the need for countless cellular antennas. Paging and wireless
internet services require similar antennas, and many businesses are
placing satellite dishes on their roofs to transmit and receive data from
their corporate headquarters. Increasingly popular satellite television
services require subscribers to install reception dishes, while amateur
radio operators want to install huge antenna arrays to communicate around
the world. As these antennas proliferate, so do community concerns about
health, safety, and aesthetic impacts. Each of these antennas has its own
maze of federal and state regulations limiting local authority. Yet most
local staff have little knowledge of these regulations or even how to go
about finding them. This book is intended to overcome this problem.
The Challenge. The challenge for both the regulator and the regulated is
becoming greater as new technologies emerge that donšt fit squarely into
established categories. Traditionally, telecommunications services divided
into two types (telephone and cable television) and local government had
different, but relatively clear authority to regulate each under federal
and state law. However, as new technologies develop, overlap, and even
merge, determining the regulatory category that applies to a particular
service or facility is problematic. For example, it is unclear the extent
to which local governments can regulate cable modem service (Internet
access provided over a cable line), because it is unclear whether it is a
cable service, a telecommunications service, or something else. This book
will help the reader understand these developing issues.
This book is not intended to be read from cover to cover, but is instead a
resource to gain background when a particular issue arises. While its
primary focus is legal, the book is addressing both lawyers and
non-lawyers. It contains brief summaries of many court decisions, but the
reader should refer to the decisions themselves for a complete
understanding of the case. On occasion, discussion of a case will include
an extensive quote when a case is particularly significant and when a mere
summary would not do justice to the language used.
While California law is often discussed, the primary emphasis is federal
law, making this book a useful resource for practitioners in other states.
Nevertheless, readers outside California should also become familiar with
the laws of their own state that may relate to issues raised in this book.
Because telecommunications law is very complicated and constantly
changing, government and industry staff face a formidable challenge doing
their jobs in a manner consistent with the law. It is our hope that this
book will help in that task.
|